“why you gotta be so mean” -taylor swift (and before you scoff, read on)

page from my latest project

A couple of  weekends ago I went to a Natural Parenting Expo.  The good things about this were:

I met up with some delightful friends

No one minded when I let Addair Kentucky nurse in public

I bought two new diaper covers (the next size up!) without having to drive to the store

I got to visit the Lisa Ross Birthing Center booth and heard some good news (another secret!  that I will tell you about later)

However, my visit wasn’t an all together pleasant one.  Upon arriving, I was accosted by an amped up baby-wearing mom about the evils of my particular baby carrier.  I can’t tell you what she said specifically because I was focused on not crying but it was something like, “You are causing your baby’s hips to dislocate by him letting face out like that” with a tone that implied, “I am expert and you, oh silly, little know-nothing, should have read up on this.  You obviously aren’t one of us.”  Sniffle, sniffle.  She called on her fellow Natural Parents to back her up, “Yeah, I mean, no offense, but that just looks totally uncomfortable.”  She was also kind enough to inform me that I was using the absolute worst cloth diaper covers.  On and on it went while I swallowed that quivery tearful feeling.

detail from another page

I’m a sentimental soul and besides being a fragile new mama, the carrier was the same one my mama used to carry my little sisters.  Perhaps its an Appalachian complex but I hate pretension and my feelings get awful hurt when it comes to a mean thing said about my kin folk.  I looked around the room full of parents puffed up with artificial confidence that comes from convening with people like yourself and imagined everyone looking on me with pity and scorn for carrying a “crotch dangler” (yes! they really sat that) and so I sheepishly took baby Addair out of his carrier and held him all the time I stayed.

Apparently you aren’t suppose to let babies face forward in Baby Bjorns, but that’s beside the point.  The thing I want to talk about is this relentless pursuit of us humans to create insiders and outsiders.

We tend to create circles of expertise.  Whether its on a particular sport, religion, fashion, or hobby; we create easily identifiable characteristics to let the in-crowd know who’s in and who’s out.  It’s elite snobbishness and really quite foolish.  I was chatting with a friend about this and she thinks this sort of behavior is driven by a craving for identity.  I think she’s right.  It’s just a readymade way to feel good about ourselves.

We all want love, even if it means that we withhold love to get it.  I’ve seen this over and over.  People bond over bashing whoever isn’t there at the moment.  It starts as children and we just keep doing it.

Artist are awful for doing this.  I felt incredibly disparaged when I learned that “professional/academic” artists don’t sign their canvases.  Apparently it was a dead giveaway for an amauter or commercial artist and I had been happily showing myself the idiot for many many paintings.  Well, humbug, I say.  Now I sign my name prominently without even relegating it to the bottom corner because boo hiss thats the way I like to paint.  And even though I’m not putting baby facing outward in his Bjorn (just in case) I am being careful about creating an identity based solely on motherhood or any other title, interest, or style.

 

 

[ from ashley who is listening to Beastie Boys (Ill Communication) ]

 

 

 

 

 

Ashley Addair liked this post

Reader Comments (16)

  1. Kate said:

    What a great post, Ashley! You’re right about it all, and I like ur signature and my baby bjorn! :-)

    • Ashley said:

      yeah! thanks, kate we’re starting to get out and about again on first fridays so hope we get to visit with you soon

      Reply

  2. rebekah said:

    oh when i first read this i was SO mad…wish i’d have been there! boo hiss and piss on ‘em….i’d have said that not only were your little sisters hips NOT dislocated, they have no long term hip problems AND ysabel walked at 8 months…..pretty sure a kid with hip trouble would’ve had a hard time walking…..after being carried around for hours! at cross country meets and soccer games……also i think you should make a painting OF your signature and sign it ;-) hehe….agree with Jana…love this post…..stay original!

  3. Chrissy said:

    You’ve got to fly your own way, Ashley. I remember when Xander was small I used to go home crying a lot, too (I bottlefed, used a Bjorn, let him have a paci…so basically I was the devil incarnate to some of these mums). Your thoughts are mine exactly – it’s as though the popularity contests of junior high shift themselves to motherhood once the babies are born, and there are infinite rules to follow to the letter. And to top it off, there is such a huge cottage industry surrounding what’s right for bebe. So silly.

    Keep on keepin’ on, sweetheart. Baby is beautiful, and so are you.

    (also love the painting in this post – i think you should always sign your paintings.) xoxo

    • Ashley said:

      thanks so much
      for the encouragement, chrissy

      Reply

  4. Cassandra eldridge said:

    Ashley! This sort of broke my heart. You are doing beautifully, and no snobby-momma can take that away from you. Do your thing! Sign yo’ name! You are wonderful.

    • Ashley said:

      so grateful for your sweet words and i’ll keep your mantra dear and near haha. “sign yo’ name” love it

      Reply

  5. Jessica said:

    yeah! this is why that expression exists to “take everything with a grain of salt”! People will criticize you and others but there is no reason to hold on to their negative energies! You can just shake it off ignore them, laugh at them, pray for them because they are so wrapped up in their confusion that they were not sensitve enough to see they hurt your feelings! I know sometimes I can be critical of people and the whole time I am thinking, “Why am I being so mean and critical?” I think it’s part of the human condition, and it’s not something that is that person’s or any persons true essence, but a reflection of their separation from God, as christians would say, or their suffering, as buddhists would say… Besides,people have been raising babies since the beginning of time and I’m pretty sure MOST babies in the world are just strapped to their mom’s backs with their heads flailing about, and they grow up to be perfectly normal humans. You are the most super mom, you are giving him LOVE and that’s what a baby needs! :)

    ok that was a long message i’ll kindly come down from my soap box hehehe

    • Ashley said:

      that’s a soapbox i don’t mind one bit. thank you thank you thank you

      love love love, thats what i have to remember

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *